In their
first and highly praised book, Regulating
the Poor, Richard A. Cloward
and Frances Fox Piven, two
of America's best-known radical
social critics, documented
the rise of the welfare crisis
in America and put forth their
thesis as to its causes, effects,
and solutions. In The
Politics of Turmoil, they
have gathered their other essays
on the urban crisis, analyzing
the different aspects of the
political upheaval produced
in the cities since World War
II.
One facet
of this upheaval has been the
great black migration to the
cities and the subsequent rise
of insurgency among the black
poor themselves, taking the
form of marches, riots, rent
strikes, and welfare protest. Several
essays evaluate these movements,
showing that the relatively
closed American political system,
which often made protest the
only option available to the
poor, also finally defeated
them.
Migration
brought great numbers of blacks
into the arena of city politics,
generating the hope that they
would follow the path presumably
taken by other ethnic groups,
gaining power and patronage
through municipal politics.
Another group of essays examines
the basis for the hope in the
political structure of contemporary
American cities, and concludes
that the prospects for the realization
of black power are exceedingly
dim.
The final
essays discuss efforts by American
political elites to moderate
the disorder welling up in
the ghettos, efforts ranging
from the establishment of manpower
training and mental health
programs to the "War on
Poverty."
Modest as these programs were,
the greater irony is that the
black poor did not turn out to
be their chief beneficiaries;
sectors of the middle class profited
more. Once again, the poor
had made the trouble and others
made the gains. |